The short story: Nothing as good as what you listed, although there were quite a few great shows. There are two, maybe three shows in their final stretch right now that have a very good chance of being at or near god tier in my book. Have you watched anything since Madoka and Steins;Gate? That was what, Spring 2011? I'll just cover the last year or so.
-If you've missed all the way back to Spring 2012, Tsuritama and Lupin the Third: The Woman Called Fujiko Mine were stellar. They're my favorites of the completed shows I'm about to mention. Very high ranking for me. There was also Sakamichi no Apollon (Shinichiro Watanabe and Yoko Kanno reunite), which I didn't finish. It was well-received, but had a hard time living up to the massive expectations of Cowboy Bebop.
-Summer 2012 was a dark, ugly time for anime. Sword Art Online got a lot of hype and was entertaining enough. Not a classic by any means, though. It can be skipped. If you enjoyed Black Lagoon, both seasons of Jormungand should be a great watch. Kyousogiga was a great little ONA that completely deserves a full blown show. Humanity Has Declined was the surprise of the summer season. Again, not a classic by any means, but definitely a unique, funny show.
-Fall brought quite a few good picks. Except none of the good ones are actually done yet. Four or five weeks to go. Psycho-Pass and to a lesser amount, Shin Sekai Yori are my potential god tier picks. They're really gonna have to crash and burn to flunk. Psycho-Pass spends maybe 2 or 3 too many episodes as what seems to be an episodic cyber-detective show but then around episode 9 or 10 begins tying it all together and shifts gears to a spectacular sci-fi focused on what makes a criminal. Shin Sekai Yori is a fantasy/sci-fi in a different vein and I'm a bit more of a loss to quantify it in a sentence or two. ESP becomes standard among the few remaining humans, and it follows a pretty spread-out time line with some good twisting and turning. pomegranate just hit the fan and it's very satisfying at the moment, despite a slow start. Robotics;Notes is another good pick from Fall that's finishing up. It's biggest problem is that it's the next title from the Steins;Gate guys. Tough act to follow. The plot moves a little slowly and none of plot lines have really come together yet. There's still time for that but since I'm not familiar with the source VN, I'm 50/50 on whether it will end as just "another good show" or something more.
Magi is a terrifically satisfying shounen that started in Fall, if you're into that. There's also JoJo's Bizzare Adventure and Zetsuen no Tempest. I've fallen behind on both to the point where I'm just going to let them finish and marathon the last 2/3rds of each. JoJo is hard to pass up. It's the definition of over-the-top. I actually enjoy gg's troll Cockney English fansubs to add to the absurdity. I was starting to bore of Tempest after the first 4ish episodes, but I've only read good things since, and it's more or less a genre I enjoy.
Oh, and Nekomonogatari.
I can't give much input on many slice-of-life/moeblob/romcoms. Not my area.
Bookmarks