[Game Over] A Song of Ice and Mafia TOWN WINS

[Shidoshi]

Attempts at your life during the day might also be limited to Day Vigilante kind of things, unless you already clarified that it counts lynch as well with HolyPie.
Edit: day is over.

[Olsi]

I mean if maspan isnt a wight then we know yoshi is full of pomegranate and will probably kill him next day. However no one counter claimed despite doctor still being alive.

[Holypie]

Attempts at your life during the day might also be limited to Day Vigilante kind of things, unless you already clarified that it counts lynch as well with HolyPie.
Edit: day is over.

What? no there's still like 43 minutes. Keep posting this is interesting :D

[MasPan]

I mean if maspan isnt a wight then we know yoshi is full of pomegranate and will probably kill him next day. However no one counter claimed despite doctor still being alive.

He's full of pomegranate regardless, but that's a separate matter from my role/power. And it may very well be limited to a vigilante type thing, which would utterly piss me off if it caused me to die today.

[y0y0y0y0shi0]

Assuming the wildlings didn't fail to kill me simply because they didn't KNOW I was a wight. It's possible that a kill would work the second time once they figure out what they're doing, but my role PM doesn't specify it. It says I can survive attempts on my life in either time period (day/night), but it doesn't explicitly say how many or even if there is a limit.

-Edit-
In fact, now that I think about it, that would make perfect sense - a failed first attempt but the second, knowing who/what I was, being successful. Well crap. That scares me.

Because your statement literally only had a negative connotation, that's my point. You basically said that you're willing to sacrifice verrkol as a townie to save your own skin with the added benefit of gaining some information about who voted him off, one of the people being you. Optimal scenarios should always be strived for. Sacrificing townies for small amounts of information is hardly optimal.

Edit: oops quoted wrong post too late

[VerrKol]

What? no there's still like 43 minutes. Keep posting this is interesting :D

It's hard telling time when you're as old as Aemon. All that timey-wimey stuff runs together.

[Holypie]

Riding high after your victories the previous day, many accusations and arguments are thrown around, but it seems clear that the victim of the day is to be MasPan. There were even some accusations of him being a white walker of legend. As the sun sets, he is placed on the block. "It won't do a thing to me", he says, confident that he'll survive even a beheading. The sword swings down, and shatters upon his neck. "I told you, it's useless". At a loss for what to do, you go to sleep praying that something will get you out of your current mess.

Night 3 will end tomorrow at 12 PM EST (sorry for the lateness again, I have a class that ends at 9 then I have to commute home ;_;).

Actually I'm going to end the night at 6 PM EST, and give some extra time for discussion the next day. If anyone wants me to change it back to 12 PM I can do that too, but say so in the discussion thread.

[Holypie]

You wake up and head to the yard once again to take a look at who died this time. Upon arrival, you see the body of the resident blacksmith of Castle Black, Donal Noye (VerrKol).

You are Donal Noye, the one-armed blacksmith of Castle Black. You forged a new suit of armour and you can give it to another player. The armour prevents them from being killed once. You only have one suit of armour, and you cannot give it to yourself. To give the suit of armour send me a PM at night containing [Armour] Target. You win when all threats to the realm are eliminated.

Just then, you hear stirring from the lichyard. You see the corpses of Hobb, Mance, and even Stannis lurching towards you with frightening speed, before they suddenly drop dead, the ancient magic animating them finally ending with the death of MasPan, who you all now see is quite clearly one of the White Walkers of old.

You are a White Walker, sometimes called an Other. After 8000 years you are finally taking back the land that was yours before the First Men and the Children of the Forest fought you off and put up that pesky Wall. Your speed and ice sword give you an incredible advantage in battle, and you cannot be killed by normal means. You can survive one attempt on your life each phase before the humans learn of your weaknesses and begin using dragonglass weapons. If you are discovered by the servants of the Red God they will expose your weakness immediately and your protection will be lost. You can fight back though, and once a night you may send me a PM containing [Resurrect] Target to bring a dead player back to life as a wight. You may only resurrect the same person once. Every three wights you raise increases the weight of your vote by one and you start the game with two wights under your control. If your vote counts for more than half of the votes on the day’s lynch, that lynch victim is immediately brought back as a wight. Your vote cannot count for more than three, and you cannot have the majority vote by yourself. You win if you are alive when the number of wights is greater than the number of living humans left in the game.

You breathe a sigh of relief upon seeing his body, knowing that a great threat to the realm has been eliminated.

Day 4 will end at 11 pm EST on Thursday, as usual.

[Olsi]

Well then.... besides maspans craziness who was donal noye?

[Shidoshi]

Donal Noye only exists in the books, he is the blacksmith at Castle Black. His important acts were diluted in other characters in the show.

I think we're far enough along that leaving behind a trail of inactive players is not benefiting us.
[Vote] ChaoticCJ
Showed up yesterday voting for VerrKol, who turned to be some kind of doctor. He was also complaining that other people were being inactive / airheaded while he was being inactive for the whole game until the last Day.
He didn't participate in the LuvD wagon, pointed his suspicion of VerrKol many times throughout other Days while not committing to a vote until the last Day, mentioned many times that he wanted to wait until we had more information.

For the most part he's been on the sidelines with only minimal posts enough to stay out of the "completely afk" zone.

[Olsi]

My bad, holypie didnt have verrkols name there when i saw it which is why i asked

[meowmixx]

:3 quite glad to know the Great Other is gone. But I am curious, who killed him since i guess the Mafia killed Verrkol

[ChaoticCJ]

Donal Noye only exists in the books, he is the blacksmith at Castle Black. His important acts were diluted in other characters in the show.

I think we're far enough along that leaving behind a trail of inactive players is not benefiting us.
[b][Vote] ChaoticCJ;[b]
Showed up yesterday voting for VerrKol, who turned to be some kind of doctor. He was also complaining that other people were being inactive / airheaded while he was being inactive for the whole game until the last Day.
He didn't participate in the LuvD wagon, pointed his suspicion of VerrKol many times throughout other Days while not committing to a vote until the last Day, mentioned many times that he wanted to wait until we had more information.

For the most part he's been on the sidelines with only minimal posts enough to stay out of the "completely afk" zone.

I wasn't complaining, more disappointed, and I was responding to yoshi's comment. To address day 2: I also didn't vote for Luv because I said I was going to be out for the rest of the day and didn't want to put out a vote that I may have regretted later (this was before Luv came out with his "role"). I actually explicitly posting in both threads that I would not be voting because I didn't want my vote to be using one way or another like is is now. Remember that I agreed with VerrKol about his suspicions on you on day 2, and was the only one who wanted more information on day 3-then you bandwaggoned with MasPan because...well you said he was suspicious. Honestly, it was VerrKol who kinda gave away that he had some type of doctor role-I said so in my post on day two.

I am curious as to why you say that "leaving a trail of inactive player is not benefiting us," then accuse me of being inactive (which I don't deny), then push a lynch against me? If leaving a trail of inactive players behind isn't benefiting us, why not vote for someone more...active? I am just curious...we know how the inactive TheBirds lynch went...

This actually points to a question then...why didn't you protect MasPan? I can understand not protecting VerrKol since you were the first to go after him, but then who did you target?

If you want to vote for me, so be it, but if you have payed attention you should know who I am and my "ability." I suggest you look at my votes and posts again. I don't post much for a reason-because I believe words are much more effective when used sparingly.

I am going to wait for the others before throwing accusation around. Also, at this point I am also going to say that my night was again...uneventful.

[Polantaris]

Donal Noye only exists in the books, he is the blacksmith at Castle Black. His important acts were diluted in other characters in the show.

I think we're far enough along that leaving behind a trail of inactive players is not benefiting us.
[Vote] ChaoticCJ;
Showed up yesterday voting for VerrKol, who turned to be some kind of doctor. He was also complaining that other people were being inactive / airheaded while he was being inactive for the whole game until the last Day.
He didn't participate in the LuvD wagon, pointed his suspicion of VerrKol many times throughout other Days while not committing to a vote until the last Day, mentioned many times that he wanted to wait until we had more information.

For the most part he's been on the sidelines with only minimal posts enough to stay out of the "completely afk" zone.

In this vein, I'm going to [Vote] @Salguod;.

He's even less active than CJ, and quite frankly we've seen almost nothing of him in the game.

I am curious as to why you say that "leaving a trail of inactive player is not benefiting us," then accuse me of being inactive (which I don't deny), then push a lynch against me? If leaving a trail of inactive players behind isn't benefiting us, why not vote for someone more...active? I am just curious...we know how the inactive TheBirds lynch went...

This actually points to a question then...why didn't you protect MasPan? I can understand not protecting VerrKol since you were the first to go after him, but then who did you target?

I don't follow your reasoning in the first part. "If a trail of inactives don't help us, why not lynch someone active?"

And why would they have protected MasPan? Who would have?

[y0y0y0y0shi0]

I rest my case. That was infinitely more difficult than it should've been, thank you to whoever killed him.

Last night i gossip'd CJ for essentially the same reasons that Shidoshi has now, and I left thinking he was a loyal member of the watch, which I assume means he's town. I had assumed Shidoshi was a thrall of Mas and didn't think there was much of a point inspecting them if that were the case.

That being said, although I can see the intentions behind Shidoshi's vote, the fact that they're the one doing it makes no sense. This is the second time now that they've voted someone for doing nearly the same things they're doing. Shidoshi came in yesterday to randomly follow up the vote on verrkol with little to no explanation, but now voting verrkol is convicting CJ?

[Olsi]

Meow has pretty much done nothing and i dont really like his over the top replies so my focus is on him for now

[y0y0y0y0shi0]

Here are my thoughts so far:

Olsi: showed a decent amount of precaution yesterday and it seemed like he was genuinely trying to form a correct opinion on the matter, probably town
Meow: playing *exactly* the same as they did last game, albeit with a bit less uhhh zeal(?) which I could probably chalk up to the fact that we killed 2 mafia early and the situation doesn't necessarily call for fervor, almost certainly town
CJ: probably town, if only for my investigation
Polantaris: i said early on that i was confident they were town but their attitude seems to have shifted a bit from before and between the drama yesterday I didn't have much of a chance to make anything of it
Meta: I feel like they could be lying about their role (as town or scum) but I don't know what to make of them from their sort-of-inactivity.
Salguod: again, don't really know what to make of them from their inactivity, possibly a bit scummier than meta in this regard but I haven't seen them play before so who knows
Shidoshi: I've said for most of the game that they've seemed super scummy.

[meowmixx]

Meow has pretty much done nothing and i dont really like his over the top replies so my focus is on him for now

There is/was (not sure yet) a reason for everything. Just believe and have faith

Edit: Yes I am less fabulous than I was in the last game. Sincere apologies for that

[MetaSeraphim]

Meow has pretty much done nothing and i dont really like her over the top replies so my focus is on her for now

Typical meow game.

Meta: I feel like they could be lying about their role (as town or scum) but I don't know what to make of them from their sort-of-inactivity.

Naw, what I've said before is true. I am Grenn, a brother of the Night’s Watch. I have no powers and will gain no powers.

[y0y0y0y0shi0]

Also nobody's pointed out in Mas' pm: "servants of the Red God." Specifically servant​S

edit: also I guess shidoshi unvoted while I was typing my first post?