[Game Over] Bad Apple Mafia - Mafia Victory

[MetaSeraphim]

Im more concerned about why you were acting like a drunk

I was planning on acting like such so I wouldn't get much attention and I could find out more, but I've already said too much so it is too late to go back now.

[Kyrastri]

Sorry I just woke up!

Killing y0y0y0y0shi0 seems like two birds with one stone for the mafia. Off an active player and incriminate ChaoticCJ. I don't want to write off suspicion on CJ just yet, but I think there are others that should take the fall first.
[Vote] CakesXD

Please reassess your suspicion on CJ, lest you want to core another green apple.

I am now very suspicious of @MetaSeraphim;, since I don't think two cops in a game makes a lot of sense. He has not, however, mentioned anything about my investigation on Chaotic, so I can't be sure.

@Corn; Hello, I'm Gilded Gilly. I don't know what shade of apple I look like, but my parents always called me delicious. A little creepy if you ask me.

If me clearing Chaotic suggested otherwise, I'm a cop. Truth be told I didn't want to claim this early, but I'm not willing to stand by and watch innocents be lynched, and Meta claimed as well... So I guess this is a counterclaim?

[Holypie]

Oh god dammit, it's this again. Meta are you pulling the same stunt you did last game where you pretended to be a cop?

Or maybe this time it's actually an insane/paranoid/naive cop situation.

I'm Merry Mac, a McIntosh like yoshi was (which is very strange to be honest), and I'm another goddamn detective. I investigated yoshi, which was stupid because in retrospect it's pretty obvious that he would have been the target of the mafia. Yeah this is messed up. MasPan what have you done?!?!?!

[Olsi]

Dear god.... well everyone, any thoughts on this situation?

[KhainiWest]

Well I feel the deciding factor would be if both words/chaotix confirm they had an activity last night

[MetaSeraphim]

Oh god dammit, it's this again. Meta are you pulling the same stunt you did last game where you pretended to be a cop?

No. Words is mafia, I have no doubt about it.

You turned up nothing, Kyra turned up an innocent and I turned up a mafia member.


What are we gonna do about this?

[Polantaris]

Oh god dammit, it's this again. Meta are you pulling the same stunt you did last game where you pretended to be a cop?

Or maybe this time it's actually an insane/paranoid/naive cop situation.

Isn't the same EXACT game Meta played last time...and ended up being a liar? IIRC, Meta played drunk the whole game, until suddenly, "Hey I'm a cop and here's a bunch of lies."

I'm Merry Mac, a McIntosh like yoshi was (which is very strange to be honest), and I'm another goddamn detective. I investigated yoshi, which was stupid because in retrospect it's pretty obvious that he would have been the target of the mafia. Yeah this is messed up. MasPan what have you done?!?!?!

Interestingly, I'm also a McIntosh apple. Was hoping to pull a, "Computers were named after me," joke later down the road but now that's ruined...

[Kyrastri]

Or maybe this time it's actually an insane/paranoid/naive cop situation.

I'm Merry Mac, a McIntosh like yoshi was (which is very strange to be honest), and I'm another goddamn detective. I investigated yoshi, which was stupid because in retrospect it's pretty obvious that he would have been the target of the mafia. Yeah this is messed up. MasPan what have you done?!?!?!

Seriously? Three cops in a game? That's a little much... o_o

And I actually wanted to investigate y0y0, since I did vote for him, but it was Chaotic's vote for Sega that sealed the deal for me. He said that he "had" to vote Sega, implying that he couldn't vote for words... So maybe he was coerced into a vote?

Edit: or words is mafia. I'm a dolt.

[MetaSeraphim]

Well I feel the deciding factor would be if both words/chaotix confirm they had an activity last night

Problem with that.

Say Kyra is an insane cop and CJ is actually a mafia member he could confirm he was looked at last night and appear innocent as far as anyone is concerned. Say I am the sane cop and Words say he wasn't looked at last night and makes me look bad.

Of course it is possible any of the three of us are insane so. . .

[Holypie]

Honestly, if Mas designed this game anything like the old SP Mafia games, this isn't surprising in the least. Those were the most power role heavy, unbalanced games I've ever seen, and they were great. Anyway nostalgia aside, there's a very simple way to resolve this. Meta, Kyrastri, and I should all investigate the same person, and then lynch that person. I'm fairly certain this is a case of multiple cops and this should shed light on the mental status of all of us. Whoever the doctor is, you're going to have a fun night tonight. At the moment, I think it's safe to say that lynching Words would be good for confirmation for Meta.

[KhainiWest]

Lynch meta, investigate words.

Explanation to follow;

[Holypie]

Also in none of the games I have ever played is the target of an investigation revealed to have been investigated. That leads to ALL SORTS OF NONSENSE like mafia being alerted that they've been exposed, or easy innocent confirmation, or whatever. I don't see why CJ and Words having night actions is relevant. Kyrastri, did the result PM say that CJ is a green apple specifically? Like, it told you what type of apple he was? Did it say anything about alignment? For all we know a green apple could be rotten. If it's not insanity that we're dealing with, it could be a case of different cops investigating different traits. Checking now, my role PM doesn't say anything about determining the alliance of the person I investigate. It just says searching a target for clues about their identity. Meta and Kyra, what were the exact verbs that you're using to investigate? My verb is Investigate. God damn this is more of a mess than I thought.

[MetaSeraphim]

Lynch meta, investigate words.

I admit it is possible that I am an insane cop but y'all would end up lynching off a possible good cop that way. If Words doesn't turn out to be mafia then everyone is gonna come after me tomorrow if I live through the night, that is a fact. But voting me off now would get rid of an ally of the town and give the mafia a pick between two people to kill instead of three.

Meta and Kyra, what were the exact verbs that you're using to investigate?

Spy On

[ChaoticCJ]

I am pretty busy today, so this may be the only post for a little. I am short on time and a good amount has happened so I am a bit confused.


About yesterday: I didn't want to vote for Sega or Words because it would be too easy for the mafia to tip the vote, but I was forced to after the votes piled on in a snipe attempt (I was afraid that Shidoshi may have double vote and given the multiple cops claim now and everyone claiming to have an ability yesterday, I was right to worry). I thought that yoshi and Shidoshi were protecting Verkoll or Words, but it doesn't make sense given the new information.


As for today, I am a bit lost. I am obviously going to side with Kyrastri, but I am a bit surprised the cops would come out with only one night of information. I right now am siding with KhainiWest that some seem to be hiding.

I am tight on time, so I will hopefully be able to take in all the information later today.

[Kyrastri]

Also in none of the games I have ever played is the target of an investigation revealed to have been investigated. That leads to ALL SORTS OF NONSENSE like mafia being alerted that they've been exposed, or easy innocent confirmation, or whatever. I don't see why CJ and Words having night actions is relevant. Kyrastri, did the result PM say that CJ is a green apple specifically? Like, it told you what type of apple he was? Did it say anything about alignment? For all we know a green apple could be rotten. If it's not insanity that we're dealing with, it could be a case of different cops investigating different traits. Checking now, my role PM doesn't say anything about determining the alliance of the person I investigate. It just says searching a target for clues about their identity. Meta and Kyra, what were the exact verbs that you're using to investigate? My verb is Investigate. God damn this is more of a mess than I thought.

Investigate. The contents of my pm, to paraphrase, indicated that Chaotic was an apple, then said that it was green. It was two sentences.


He showed up "green" on my investigation. I'm guessing it's either -colour- or rotten, though I haven't found a mafia yet.

Edit: @ChaoticCJ; I didn't want to come out and claim, since my only result seemed to be innocent, but I didn't want to let everyone fall for what could be a liar/insane cop.

I'm kinda glad you didn't come off as rotten, it means that we can now focus on other people without lynching an innocent. If you came off as a mafia, I reckon a lot of people wouldn't be able to believe the cops entirely...

[Holypie]

Investigate. The contents of my pm, to paraphrase, indicated that Chaotic was an apple, then said that it was green. It was two sentences.


He showed up "green" on my investigation. I'm guessing it's either -colour- or rotten, though I haven't found a mafia yet.

Edit: ChaoticCJ; I didn't want to come out and claim, since my only result seemed to be innocent, but I didn't want to let everyone fall for what could be a liar/insane cop.

I'm kinda glad you didn't come off as rotten, it means that we can now focus on other people without lynching an innocent. If you came off as a mafia, I reckon a lot of people wouldn't be able to believe the cops entirely...

Neither did I but then I saw TWO!?!?! cops and then I thought that Meta wouldn't be stupid enough to pull the same trick twice (no offense, sorry) and also he isn't doing the same thing as last time where he popped in to reveal and then vanished. He's much more active which leads me to believe that he's telling the truth.

Kyra, I think we have a similar role in that it's not a full cop, more like a hint cop. With this information I don't think Meta is insane, and barring more cops coming out I think we should [vote] Words

[Kyrastri]

Neither did I but then I saw TWO!?!?! cops and then I thought that Meta wouldn't be stupid enough to pull the same trick twice (no offense, sorry) and also he isn't doing the same thing as last time where he popped in to reveal and then vanished. He's much more active which leads me to believe that he's telling the truth.

Kyra, I think we have a similar role in that it's not a full cop, more like a hint cop. With this information I don't think Meta is insane, and barring more cops coming out I think we should [vote] Words

I agree, though I'm curious to see Khaini's theory behind his suggestion to investigate Words and to kill Meta. I don't think we should kill him, though; a cop is a cop and it would be good to keep more cops around to ensure that we get at least one investigation done and proper.

[Olsi]

(Was in a LoL game gimmie a second to read this all)

[Corn]

Guys guys it's too pineappleing early to have 3 fake cops, I did it on Day 3 in the last mafia remember?

[Words]

There's a lot going on right now. Starting with Meta's claim first, she's lying, I'm just a townie and I see three possibilities: 1) She's an insane/paranoid cop, 2) She's the fool, acting drunk at first and then making a false claim with a false guilty to get herself lynched later (which, if I understand correctly, fits what Olsi says about his pm) and 3) she pulling weird shenanigans for whoever knows what reason. It's any of those because I don't know if mafia would pull something like this so early so I don't list it. I'm right about one of them but loosing her would be a loss for the town.

Second, HolyPie is right about getting pm because you were investigated. I didn't get one and I notice ChaoticCJ didn't even mention it so I'm going to guess it's the same for him. Either way, not getting pms doesn't tell us anything, it could be true or lies that they investigated us and we wouldn't know.

Lastly, it didn't surprise me that there was a counter claim because of Meta's "results" but the other claim did confuse me. The way I see all this claiming is, Meta fits the two last possibilities I listed above (that's why I bolded them); the real cop is either HolyPie and Kyrastri; the other would be an insane/paranoid cop or mafia seizing the chaos.