To those who've quit: What would make you come back?

I think a better question would be what would make new players join? People who left aren't likely to come back.

They're really one in the same.

People who are looking to join will hear about all the same problems we all have: No GM activity, too p2w, etc. Those are all huge turn offs for people, and as a result stop new players from joining. Essentially, people who left just spread the word of what's wrong with the game, and stop new people from joining. If they fixed those things, we wouldn't have anything bad to say about the game unless we just didn't like the gameplay, which is purely based upon opinion so you can't change that anyway.