Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword [SPOILERS]

That's the problem with the opinions on new entries to long standing IPs. People want the IP to be redone into something new, but still feel like that IP. I had an argument with a friend yesterday about how the game began very hand holdy and that the dowsing mechanics were a bit faulty for being either too useful, or not useful at all (his main example was the first visit to eldin while looking for the keys, specifically the fire room where you have to dowse before you enter in order to take the right direction)

And do these opinions effect your experience with the game? Im sure if you are a Zelda fan you'd buy each game regardless of any negative comments.

Not true, I decided to stray away from phantom hourglass and spirit tracks because of the controls. But I jumped on Skyward sword because it struck a good balance between a new control scheme and old game mechanics.