2008-07-19, 03:51 PM
Its probably just me but I have trouble reading the text in the first one (probably cause this monitor makes everything darker than it really is and whatnot >_>). It looks nice and really well done though. 8/10
The second one looks nicely done but there's nothing there that separates it from the "average nice looking signature". There's nothing wrong with that, its just that I always like to see things that stand out (after all, if everyone is using something similar, it must mean that its good, hence why everyone is using it). 8/10 as well.
The last one is an art thing, meaning its based a lot on personal preference. I usually prefer more of a "refined" art style that looks more detailed and realistic (I hope you wont take offense at that >_<). That being said, the idea is good and it captures an atmosphere that is nice so I'll say 7/10 (sorry =X).
The second one looks nicely done but there's nothing there that separates it from the "average nice looking signature". There's nothing wrong with that, its just that I always like to see things that stand out (after all, if everyone is using something similar, it must mean that its good, hence why everyone is using it). 8/10 as well.
The last one is an art thing, meaning its based a lot on personal preference. I usually prefer more of a "refined" art style that looks more detailed and realistic (I hope you wont take offense at that >_<). That being said, the idea is good and it captures an atmosphere that is nice so I'll say 7/10 (sorry =X).