2014-06-01, 07:18 AM
Holypie Wrote:Seriously guys? Just because Niernen isn't helpful doesn't mean that you IGNORE A COP'S INVESTIGATION. Also can you explain what you mean by my votes ending in an innocent's death in the night?
I'm putting everything on the line for this, because I think it's right. Besides, it's very unusual for a pirafia to counterclaim a cop. The much more common scenario is that a pirafia is backed into a corner and comes out as a cop as a last ditch effort to live for a while longer, and then the real cop counterclaims. This isn't all the time, but I think this is what's going on now. If you think I'm suspicious because I've suddenly been posting a whole lot more, it's because I'm having a lot of fun and scenarios like this are why I play mafia. I think this is great but you guys should really kill VerrKol. Damn if I'm wrong I'm going to look so guilty.
Polantaris basically explained it best, but lets go down the list.
ChaoticCJ - I am a survivor which was pretty obvious when I voted for Zelkova.
Niernen - As Polantaris explained, has not been all to helpful. By not joining the discussion is a threat that is left unchecked.
Olsi - Possible pirate mafia but with much less exposure and a good vote record it doesn't seem so.
Polantaris - Voted for Zelkova, which pretty much confirms survivor.
VerrKol - Same with Zelkova, even if pirate, much less of a threat than Niernen.
Corn - The cop thing was a total surprise. I thought he was innocent till he said that.
HolyPie - Voted for TheBirds (Died Night 1), ImagineAll, and Sega. All survivor, so your voting record isn't something to be proud of.
MetaSeraphim - The cop thing was again a surprise. In all honesty with Corn it is hard to tell.
xBTAx - With all of island B it is really hard to tell...
If I had to guess, right now the mafia would be Niernen, Corn, and xBTAx.
__________________________
Okay wait I had more explanation but a quick question...
You said that we would "IGNORE A COP'S INVESTIGATION" and go after Niernen. Corn's same investigation found Meta innocent...but you voted from him...which doesn't make sense...it would actually make much more sense to go after BTA. Even Corn seems like a better target than Meta since you don't want to "IGNORE A COP'S INVESTIGATION." Right? Did I miss something?