2013-06-25, 10:06 PM
Correct me if I'm mistaken, but based on the screenshot of the person that failed, it most likely happened as the crafter is only level 75. This question was asked before at the MSEA board and I'm pretty sure your crafting skill for such things must be level 10 and your level has to be 21 levels above the item too for level 10 items*. This is based on how my level 144 Bowmaster and level 200 Phantom have a success rate of 90% and 100% respectively on crafting Empress Capes, with both having maxed Smithing at that time.
*And yes, with level 10 potions and some ammo it is indeed 90% maxed. No idea why.
*And yes, with level 10 potions and some ammo it is indeed 90% maxed. No idea why.