Suggestion for potential done right

I think you might have misunderstood the point of this topic. People are informally suggesting different scenarios that would change the system for the better. They are proposed scenarios that promotes positive change by trying to save a terrible system with compromises while my informal suggestion is to simply get rid of the terrible system which, imo, is the best case scenario for the playerbase, however unlikely the scenario might be.

It's a thought experiment, not a professionally edited proposal that would be on the agenda of the boardroom at Nexon that was promised to be highly considered. I don't see other people in this thread grading posts on how "realistic" it might be since everything in this thread is just personal opinion and what they feel is best.

It seems that people like you are taking these posts way too seriously.

In that case, it should have been entitled "Pipe-dream for potential done right" and been posted in the MapleAdditions forum, where all fantasies and wishful thinking go.
"Suggestion" generally implies that it's being presented to someone who can implement it, and stands a chance to be convinced to do so. You can't fault people for trying to view such things realistically.