Insane Asylum Mafia Discussion.

Pretty sure it was Shidoshi, Holypie, Hypermug, nobody, LuvD. Meow killed me before I could burn Holypie, which kindof bugs me because I sent that PM in eaaaaaaaaaaarly on Day 6 and basically had to sit there looking like an idiot waiting for it to go off while people accused me of being useless.

It just seemed so suspicious that you kept claiming to be able to burn people but nothing ever happened. I dunno why it never went off, but we were actually hoping you would burn people. The sooner you burned people the sooner we would have won. That's why I called you useless at the end, because it kept making things SO MUCH more uncertain for us. Every time I thought we had it, it dealt with you also killing people to give us majority...and then nothing happened.

As CJ said, we never attacked you. Didn't know Shidoshi was a CPR doctor, it was confusing me like crazy every time you brought up that you were attacked on Day 1, especially after Meow said they had a hiding role, not a redirecting role.

LOL.. That's funny.

Polantaris was like so suss but I didn't have enough evidence to prove it

MY GUTS WERE RIGHT SINCE DAY 1 OMG.

Yep. I said as much on the game thread. My game was pomegranate. But, to be honest, the game was almost entirely completely random speculation. Holypie even admitted to not using any real facts to determine who to go after. My A game is in analysis, and there was just too little to analyze. Even if I were town I would have sucked this game.

It just seemed so suspicious that you kept claiming to be able to burn people but nothing ever happened. I dunno why it never went off, but we were actually hoping you would burn people. The sooner you burned people the sooner we would have won. That's why I called you useless at the end, because it kept making things SO MUCH more uncertain for us. Every time I thought we had it, it dealt with you also killing people to give us majority...and then nothing happened.

As CJ said, we never attacked you. Didn't know Shidoshi was a CPR doctor, it was confusing me like crazy every time you brought up that you were attacked on Day 1, especially after Meow said they had a hiding role, not a redirecting role.



Yep. I said as much on the game thread. My game was pomegranate. But, to be honest, the game was almost entirely completely random speculation. Holypie even admitted to not using any real facts to determine who to go after. My A game is in analysis, and there was just too little to analyze. Even if I were town I would have sucked this game.

But kudos for winning. I practically screwed up the whole Town, hence the tied votes.

I'm really, really sorry, Town I never meant to do so. I did not count the votes in Day 1, and I was not planning that people would follow me in Day 2.

It feels kinda weird losing making just a single mislynch on a miller, I feel there was just too much kill power in the game that lynching was almost pointless. The tied vote rule really screws up the town, that's why I prefer my version of it.
I have to take a second look at all the roles there were, but it sure seemed like town got the short end of the stick.

Mafia had a bunch of strong roles while town was full of deceptive roles that made our lives harder, CPR doctor without knowing it is pretty crazy, I'm surprised I didn't kill anyone, haha.

It feels kinda weird losing making just a single mislynch on a miller, I feel there was just too much kill power in the game that lynching was almost pointless. The tied vote rule really screws up the town, that's why I prefer my version of it.
I have to take a second look at all the roles there were, but it sure seemed like town got the short end of the stick.

Mafia had a bunch of strong roles while town was full of deceptive roles that made our lives harder, CPR doctor without knowing it is pretty crazy, I'm surprised I didn't kill anyone, haha.

To be fair, MasPan was a neutral, and could have easily targetted myself, CJ, or Kyra instead of a townie. Plus, the only reason there weren't more mislynches is because Luv caused two ties, giving mafia more time to pick people off and confuse everyone.

But kudos for winning. I practically screwed up the whole Town, hence the tied votes.

I'm really, really sorry, Town I never meant to do so. I did not count the votes in Day 1, and I was not planning that people would follow me in Day 2.

The first tie wasn't too big of a deal. It, combined with our attack on meowmixx failing, basically made Day 1 a complete waste of time and not even really a Day.

It feels kinda weird losing making just a single mislynch on a miller, I feel there was just too much kill power in the game that lynching was almost pointless. The tied vote rule really screws up the town, that's why I prefer my version of it.
I have to take a second look at all the roles there were, but it sure seemed like town got the short end of the stick.

Mafia had a bunch of strong roles while town was full of deceptive roles that made our lives harder, CPR doctor without knowing it is pretty crazy, I'm surprised I didn't kill anyone, haha.

Lynch power was severely cut by the tied votes, like people have already said. I haven't seen all the roles but ours were Godfather (CJ), 1-shot Strongman (Polantaris) and a normal goon (me :3) and personally I didn't find them completely out of whack.

I was actually pretty surprised that an arsonist would be in the game since the player group was pretty small. And on that note I'm not sure whether Mas would have actually joined us if he didn't get his pills or something. It would be too OP (up to four kills) for us and none of us had a recalling ability.

Good job Holypie, though it would have been nice if he actually got a innocent read lol :p That was pretty confusing.

There never were any pills lol. That was a lie to help convince the town that I wasn't antagonistic.

MasPan had a ton of bulshit stuff he was saying, it was fun watching it.

I'll answer any questions and give more details later but first there is one thing I have to share.

LF>Details

Mafia had a bunch of strong roles while town was full of deceptive roles that made our lives harder, CPR doctor without knowing it is pretty crazy, I'm surprised I didn't kill anyone, haha.

The only thing that really threw off the balance was having a neutral. I admit that was my fault because I was being biased and really wanted a neutral despite the numbers. Otherwise like it was said the Mafia only had their normal kill and their strongman kill.


As for details there isn't really much to share.

Shidoshi was a CPR doctor.

Holypie was paranoid.

meowmixx was likely the most overpowered town role since I designed her as a basic 3-shotcommuter at first and if she lived long enough, Day 6, she would get a 1-shot gun and be able to commute one last time. If CJ had decided to attack meow instead of Holy on that last night the town would've won.

Razmos was the real doctor so to speak, if Mafia had tried to attack Holypie instead of Razmos both of them would've lived. Also, Razmos would've died sooner since Shidoshi targeted Razmos N2, but Razmos also targeted Shidoshi that night and since Razmos' action had a higher priority he lived.

VerrKol was the firefighter in case there was any doubts.

Hypermug was a miller. I had thought about making him a Judas but decided that would be a bastardly thing to do.


That is about all I can think of unless anyone else wanted details on a certain thing, if so let me know.

The only thing that really threw off the balance was having a neutral. I admit that was my fault because I was being biased and really wanted a neutral despite the numbers. Otherwise like it was said the Mafia only had their normal kill and their strongman kill.


As for details there isn't really much to share.

Shidoshi was a CPR doctor.

Holypie was paranoid.

meowmixx was likely the most overpowered town role since I designed her as a basic 3-shotcommuter at first and if she lived long enough, Day 6, she would get a 1-shot gun and be able to commute one last time. If CJ had decided to attack meow instead of Holy on that last night the town would've won.

Razmos was the real doctor so to speak, if Mafia had tried to attack Holypie instead of Razmos both of them would've lived. Also, Razmos would've died sooner since Shidoshi targeted Razmos N2, but Razmos also targeted Shidoshi that night and since Razmos' action had a higher priority he lived.

VerrKol was the firefighter in case there was any doubts.

Hypermug was a miller. I had thought about making him a Judas but decided that would be a bastardly thing to do.


That is about all I can think of unless anyone else wanted details on a certain thing, if so let me know.

I'm sorry if you have posted this, but could you post the role PMs for the surviving people?

Not really any point honestly. CJ was the godfather, meow was the commuter her PM didn't say anything about what would happen on Day 6 and Holypie was the cop with only a slight hint they might not be sane.

That same hint was present in Shidoshi's PM.



And on the subject of tie votes being a no-lynch I prefer that since not truly deciding who to lynch should be punishable.