Originally Posted by
Smooth Criminal
I never knew Tenshi had expressions and a laugh like that in her. I really liked Naoi's disappearance, but I think Yuri and Hinata's weren't nearly as dramatic as they should have been. Tenshi's made my eyes water up a bit. The very end left me a bit confused, though. I don't really care much for arbitrary questions on how the world worked, but rather; a few things are quite unclear to me. Was Tenshi suggesting that she just entered the Afterlife world through a dream or in a coma just to be able to meet Otonashi, and her feelings were what caused him to leave limbo/heaven to lose his memory and go to the Afterlife world? And yeah, we're left wondering what the part after the credits meant.
I enjoyed this series, despite the fact it had so much working against it. Key took on some pretty heady concepts in this series that they were unable to flesh out in the story: like reincarnation, where they go after, and so forth. It's pretty clear they're some sophisticated ideas that Key could never hope to really answer, and it was clear that they felt oversimplifying them would take a toll in terms of how well the series would come out; but at the same time, leaving these concepts enigmatic made the series have limited options for where they could take it and how well we could understand it. As the series progressed, obvious plotholes were noticeable left and right. In addition, the series had this nasty quality of totally changing and turning the direction of where the story would go; and added with a 13-episode series, it left the story as rushed and the plot incoherent. Not to mention, as Butterfli said earlier, it was to the extent where a new "final boss" appeared out of the blue around the end of episode 10, and where we'd see a new character and the plot turning totally still around episode 12. But you know what? Despite all that, I enjoyed it. I really liked all of the characters, and I really wanted to see them get to the end. The series mostly revolved around character development, and I was able to still enjoy it despite the poor plot just because of the characters. Also, the music was pretty nice.
Overall, this was a fairly decent series, but it could have done much better with a 26 episode run.