CoG/iCoG or 9th Anniversary Prime?

[FlameOn]

Which of these scrolling options would be best for scrolling cRA armor?
Usually with the Chaos Scrolls, you'd get around +15-25 attack on average, right?
But with the new Prime Scrolls, you would get at least +90 main stat/secondary stat.

I know there's a balance between stats and attack which makes each case different, but which is better for high-funded characters?

In this scenario, it doesn't matter how hard it would be to scroll or how cost-effective either one is.

[xlxlxlxl]

It depends entirely on what your current stats are. Post your total attack before %attack and your total main stat and substat before %stats if you want a calculation.

The attack is probably better for any character other than Xenon. DB and Shad have 2 secondary stats, so they benefit more than others from all stat as well.

[ShinkuDragon]

pretty much what xlxlxl said, it's entirely dependant on each person and what's best for you might not be the best for someone else.

[Green4Ever]

Even if you're going off the bare minimum of what you posted (15), it still comes down to 1 att vs 6 all stat, which is roughly where most people end up at.
I would just go with the attack unless you're a Xenon. The all stat is going to be a lot less siginificant at end-game once you've got a decent amount of % Att built up, plus if you scroll all of your equips with the Prime Scrolls you'll be severely lacking in attack anyway.

[ShinkuDragon]

Even if you're going off the bare minimum of what you posted (15), it still comes down to 1 att vs 6 all stat, which is roughly where most people end up at.
I would just go with the attack unless you're a Xenon. The all stat is going to be a lot less siginificant at end-game once you've got a decent amount of % Att built up, plus if you scroll all of your equips with the Prime Scrolls you'll be severely lacking in attack anyway.

i dunno if i have bad luck or what, but my luck with chaos never takes me over 10 attack.

[SaptaZapta]

You need to compare your total w.att before any %att potential or buffs, but after any straight attack buffs you normally use, to your base mainstat + additional mainstat on gear or in buffs, but before %mainstat. Neither of these numbers is shown in the stats window, unfortunately, so there's some adding up to do.

For me with my current stats, 1 attack is only worth about 2 STR. So I'm going with the 10 allstats. But YMMV.

[Dudewitbow]

i dunno if i have bad luck or what, but my luck with chaos never takes me over 10 attack.

tis basically luck, on my journey when i scrolled empress stuff, my cape and hat and shows got 20+ attack after the end(they start at a bas of 1(?)), unluckily, the gloves with a base of 5 ended at 19.

[ShinkuDragon]

tis basically luck, on my journey when i scrolled empress stuff, my cape and hat and shows got 20+ attack after the end(they start at a bas of 1(?)), unluckily, the gloves with a base of 5 ended at 19.

my only chaosed item that has ended in double digits is my hat, with 17 attack. nothing else has ever worked for me.

anyways, @OP: if money TRULY isn't an issue, then go with chaos and returns until you get 3 attack or more per slot, on a CRA gear with 10-12 slots that translates to over 30 attack which ought to be better than 90 main stat

[Dreamer]

People seem to be underestimating how much attack people get these days. For any well funded character, prime scrolling is the way to go unless you can return scroll for 5+ attack or equivalent a minimum.